(Note: This post contains spoilers about this season of Mad Men, some of the Sopranos and probably some other shows)
One thought that occurred to me as I watched the quite satisfying and totally ballsy season finale of Mad Men was that fictional television shows tend to rely on a series of simple rules and set ups, all of which create various tensions throughout the show. Generally, the plot line of a season of a television show involves threatening those tensions, only to have the threats resolve while the tensions remain.
So, in seasons one and two of Mad Men, certain fundamental tensions existed in the show. There was always the specter of Don's marriage dissolving, of him leaving Sterling Cooper, of Pete leaving or being fired etc. etc. and so forth. In both seasons, those threats were resolved while leaving the tensions between the elements of the show intact.
The problem is, you can only keep this up for so long. One of the problems with The Sopranos, for example, is they never really had the stones to completely blow up their show's premises. One of them was detonated for them when Nancy Marchand died, but in general, they would constantly step up to the precipice... and then back away from it. Tony would go to jail... but wouldn't stay in jail. Carmela leaves Tony... but she comes back to him. Doctor Malfi is raped but doesn't ask Tony to kill her rapist even though she knows who he is. Following through on any of these three things (and countless other plot elements like them) would fundamentally change the juggling act of the show. The end result was that the show remained basically the same for a decade and got a little old after awhile. (An example from season one of Mad Men in a similar vein: I never found it believable that Don didn't fire Pete. It kinda felt like a cop-out. The show needed Pete to remain at Sterling Cooper, so he did)
This season on Mad Men, there was a palpable tension in the plotting of the show... the old premises of the show-- Don's hidden life, Don's unhappiness at Sterling Cooper, Don's failing marriage, Pete's competitions with Cosgrove, Sal's closeted homosexuality-- were getting old but they hadn't quite figured out what to do about it. What they chose to do was create an hour long heist movie that allows them to hit the Big Reset Button... now they can focus on the characters they want to focus on, they don't have to deal with Don + Betty's failing marriage now that it's flat-out failed, they can keep Pete, Joan and Peggy, Don and Roger have reconciled etc. Basically, they took everything they liked about their show, cut out everything they were bored of and decided to move on. Awesome. In a weird way, if this was the series finale, I'm not sure I'd mind.
Recent Comments